Skip to main content

Independent Research: All Fairness Scores are 100% mathematically calculated from official rulebooks and never influenced by partnerships. Some links are affiliate links where we may earn a commission (at no extra cost to you).

Updated October 2026 +50% Challenge Pass Reward

Blue Guardian vs The5ers 2026 Side-by-Side Comparison

Compare trailing drawdown rules, entry plus activation costs, payout thresholds, and copy-trading policies across 8 core dimensions.

Verified Profile
Blue Guardian Logo
Starts at $8 (25.0% OFF)
VS
Verified Profile
The5ers Logo

The5ers

Forex
Starts at $22
Bottom Line: Blue Guardian fits Forex and multi-asset traders seeking built-in Guardian Shield equity protection, 22 diverse models across 6 programs—including 2-Step Pro (10% static drawdown & 100% fee refund), 2-Step Standard, 1-Step, 3-Step, Instant Funding ($5K–$200K), and a $55 Instant Starter $5K—backed by a 100% Payout Speed Guarantee on MT5, Match-Trader, and TradeLocker., while The5ers fits Serious Forex and multi-asset traders seeking the industry's longest-standing track record (since 2016), true 100% static max drawdown across 21 models, an unprecedented $4,000,000 Bootcamp scaling ladder, and up to 100% profit splits.. Pay close attention to drawdown mechanics: Blue Guardian uses 100% Static Max Drawdown on 2-Step Standard (8%), 2-Step Pro (10%), 1-Step (6%), and 3-Step (8%); 6% Trailing Drawdown locking at Starting Balance on Instant Funding. Balance/Equity Daily Drawdown (3%–5%)., while The5ers uses 100% Static Max Drawdown based on initial starting balance (never trails upward). Balance-based daily pause (3% to 5%) depending on program.. Whichever firm you choose, link your evaluation on LogToLast to audit post-trade buffers automatically and unlock a 50% Evaluation Pass Reward discount when you pass!
Comparing: Blue Guardian The5ers
Dimension 8 Key Standards
The5ers
The5ers Forex Verified Profile
1. Quantitative Benchmark & Fairness Score
Overall Fairness
Rules: 1257
Cost: 837
Payout: 1104
Rules: 1169
Cost: 849
Payout: 1128
2. Entry Pricing, Fees & Active Promos
Cheapest Entry
$8 $11
$22
Real Total Cost
$8 Eval fee + activation fee
$22 Eval fee + activation fee
Account Sizes
$5,000 - $200,000
$2,500 - $250,000
3. Drawdown Mechanics & Hidden Traps
Drawdown Type
100% Static Max Drawdown on 2-Step Standard (8%), 2-Step Pro (10%), 1-Step (6%), and 3-Step (8%); 6% Trailing Drawdown locking at Starting Balance on Instant Funding. Balance/Equity Daily Drawdown (3%–5%).
100% Static Max Drawdown based on initial starting balance (never trails upward). Balance-based daily pause (3% to 5%) depending on program.
4. Execution Freedom & Consistency Rules
Min Days
0 Days (Instant Pass)
3 Days
Consistency Rule
0% consistency during 1-Step, 2-Step, and 3-Step evaluations (5 min days of >=0.5% profit). 20% Consistency Rule across ALL Funded and Instant accounts (best day <= 20% of total profit).
3 Profitable Days (>=0.5% profit) required on High Stakes; zero consistency rules on Bootcamp, Hyper Growth, and Summer Plan.
News Trading
Allowed
Allowed
Weekend Holding
Must Flat by Friday
Must Flat by Friday
5. Payout Policy & Capital Extraction
Profit Split
85% to trader
80% to trader
Payout Frequency
Every 7 Days (Instant Funding & Instant Starter $5K) / Bi-Weekly 14 Days (1-Step, 2-Step & 3-Step) — Backed by 100% Payout Speed Guarantee via RiseWorks & Crypto Cycle: Bi-Weekly (14 Days) or On-Demand (Instant) days
Bi-weekly on-demand payouts processed in 24–48 hours via Rise Pay, Bank Wire, Crypto (USDT), Card & HUB Credits Cycle: Every 14 Days (Bi-weekly) / Monthly / On-Demand days
Min Payout
$100
$150
First Payout Bonus
Standard 85% split * No payout caps on 1-Step or 2-Step evaluations; Instant Funding enforces a 20% single-day consistency rule with on-demand payouts after meeting withdrawal criteria.
Standard 80% split * Bi-weekly payouts with up to 100% profit split upon scaling. High Stakes payout caps are $3,000 per cycle on $50K accounts and $4,000 on $100K accounts (uncapped on scaled levels). Summer Plan caps are $2,000 on $100K and $3,000 on $200K. Bootcamp and Hyper Growth have zero payout caps. Minimum withdrawal is $150 ($300 on 50K HS, $500 on 100K HS, $250 on Summer Plan). Payout processing fees: 3.5% on Rise, Bank Wire, Crypto; 0% on HUB Credits.
6. Execution Tech, EAs & Copy Trading
Platforms
MT5, cTrader, DXtrade, TradeLocker
MT5, cTrader, TradingView
LogToLast Auto-Journaling
Supported (MT5 / Tradovate)
Supported (MT5 / Tradovate)
EA Support
Allowed Allowed (Grid & Martingale Permitted; No Arbitrage)
Allowed EAs permitted provided every position has an automatic Stop-Loss (SL); tick scalping, latency/reverse/hedge arbitrage prohibited
Copier Policy
Personal Sync OK Permitted across personal accounts owned and operated by the same trader up to $400,000 maximum allocation via MT5 Local Bridge. Prohibited on Instant Starter $5K accounts. Third-party signal copying and HFT/latency arbitrage are strictly banned.
Personal Sync OK Personal copy trading permitted between High Stakes, Summer Plan, Pro Growth and Hyper Growth accounts up to $500,000 total capital allocation. Copying from personal external master account permitted. Copying between two Bootcamp accounts is strictly prohibited.
7. Fit, Pros & Cons
Best For
Forex and multi-asset traders seeking built-in Guardian Shield equity protection, 22 diverse models across 6 programs—including 2-Step Pro (10% static drawdown & 100% fee refund), 2-Step Standard, 1-Step, 3-Step, Instant Funding ($5K–$200K), and a $55 Instant Starter $5K—backed by a 100% Payout Speed Guarantee on MT5, Match-Trader, and TradeLocker.
Serious Forex and multi-asset traders seeking the industry's longest-standing track record (since 2016), true 100% static max drawdown across 21 models, an unprecedented $4,000,000 Bootcamp scaling ladder, and up to 100% profit splits.
Avoid If
High-variance traders whose single best day exceeds 20% of total account profit (Blue Guardian enforces a 20% consistency rule across all funded accounts), traders risking more than 2% per trade idea (or >1% on Instant Starter), or scalpers holding under 2 minutes.
Traders who refuse to place a Stop-Loss within 2 minutes of trade execution (mandatory rule), high-impact news scalpers on funded High Stakes (±2m blackout), or traders wishing to copy trades between Bootcamp accounts.
Standout Advantage
22 verified models across 6 programs, signature Guardian Shield auto-close risk limiter, 100% Static Max Drawdown on 1-Step/2-Step/3-Step evaluations, 100% evaluation fee refund on 2-Step Pro, 100% Payout Speed Guarantee (7-day & 14-day cycles), and scaling up to $2,000,000.
Operating continuously since January 2016 with 4.7/5 Trustpilot (16,450+ reviews) and 4.7/5 PFM (1,366 reviews); true 100% static max drawdown (never trails up); Bootcamp scales to $4,000,000 with entry fees from $22; High Stakes scales to $500K with up to 100% split + $4,000 to $10,000 fixed cash salaries; bi-weekly payouts; and multi-platform support across MT5, cTrader, and TradingView.
Key Bottleneck
Strict 20% consistency rule across all funded accounts (best day <= 20% of total profit); requires 5 trading days of >=0.5% profit (10 days on Instant Starter); max 2% risk per trade idea; and ±5-minute news restriction on funded accounts (10-minute on Instant Starter).
Mandatory Stop-Loss within 2 minutes of execution risking max 2% per trade idea; 3.5% transaction processing commission on Rise, Wire, and Crypto withdrawals (0% on HUB Credits); and a ±2m news order execution blackout on funded High Stakes accounts.
Trade-Off Breakdown

Side-by-Side Trade-Off Breakdown

No prop firm is universally perfect. Every firm makes intentional compromises between entry price and rule leniency.

Score: 1798 pts
Unique Advantages
  • Execution Edge: 22 verified models across 6 programs, signature Guardian Shield auto-close risk limiter, 100% Static Max Drawdown on 1-Step/2-Step/3-Step evaluations, 100% evaluation fee refund on 2-Step Pro, 100% Payout Speed Guarantee (7-day & 14-day cycles), and scaling up to $2,000,000.
  • Guardian Protector Risk Engine: Built-in automated equity circuit breaker that flattens positions before hard daily limits are breached.
  • Zero Time Limits on Evaluations: Trade at your own pace with unlimited days across all 2-Step Standard, 2-Step Pro, and 1-Step programs.
  • Generous 85% to 90% Profit Split: Receive 85% baseline performance rewards on evaluation models, scaling to 90% with add-ons or scaling milestones.
Operational Bottlenecks
  • Risk Factor: Strict 20% consistency rule across all funded accounts (best day <= 20% of total profit); requires 5 trading days of >=0.5% profit (10 days on Instant Starter); max 2% risk per trade idea; and ±5-minute news restriction on funded accounts (10-minute on Instant Starter).
  • Not Recommended For: High-variance traders whose single best day exceeds 20% of total account profit (Blue Guardian enforces a 20% consistency rule across all funded accounts), traders risking more than 2% per trade idea (or >1% on Instant Starter), or scalpers holding under 2 minutes.
Score: 1746 pts
Unique Advantages
  • Execution Edge: Operating continuously since January 2016 with 4.7/5 Trustpilot (16,450+ reviews) and 4.7/5 PFM (1,366 reviews); true 100% static max drawdown (never trails up); Bootcamp scales to $4,000,000 with entry fees from $22; High Stakes scales to $500K with up to 100% split + $4,000 to $10,000 fixed cash salaries; bi-weekly payouts; and multi-platform support across MT5, cTrader, and TradingView.
  • Industry Pioneer Operating Continuously Since January 2016 with 4.7/5 Trustpilot & 4.7/5 PFM Ratings
  • 21 Diverse Account Models Across High Stakes (2-Step), Bootcamp (3-Step), Hyper Growth, Pro Growth & Summer Plans
  • Industry-Largest Scaling Ladder Scaling All the Way Up to $4,000,000 Capital on Bootcamp
Operational Bottlenecks
  • Risk Factor: Mandatory Stop-Loss within 2 minutes of execution risking max 2% per trade idea; 3.5% transaction processing commission on Rise, Wire, and Crypto withdrawals (0% on HUB Credits); and a ±2m news order execution blackout on funded High Stakes accounts.
  • Not Recommended For: Traders who refuse to place a Stop-Loss within 2 minutes of trade execution (mandatory rule), high-impact news scalpers on funded High Stakes (±2m blackout), or traders wishing to copy trades between Bootcamp accounts.
Multi-Firm Portfolio Architecture • 50% Pass Reward

Why Choose One? Diversify Across Both & Unlock 50% Off LogToLast.

Experienced prop traders never put 100% of their risk into a single firm. With LogToLast, you can organize Blue Guardian and The5ers accounts into isolated Portfolio Groups — replicating trades in ~15–35ms, auditing locked post-trade drawdown buffers after every fill, and unlocking a 50% Evaluation Pass Reward discount when you pass!

Post-Trade Buffer HUD

Automatically recalculates your locked EOD, Static, and Trailing drawdown floors after every closed fill.

Playbook Active Enforcer

Deterministic rule engine (no AI) that blocks webhooks or closes positions when you hit your Max Daily Loss.

~15–35ms Parallel Sync

Sync Tradovate, NinjaTrader (Cloud API), and MT5 (via 100% residential-IP LogToSync bridge) with $0 VPS cost.

Start 14-Day Free Portfolio Trial ($0 Today) ✓ No credit card required • ✓ Full Elite access • ✓ 50% Pass Perk
Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Direct answers regarding drawdown calculations, payout buffers, and account synchronization.

Blue Guardian starts at $8 (discounted from $8 with promo 'LOGTOLAST'), while The5ers starts at $22 (with promo 'YWZP6'). Beyond advertised evaluation sticker prices, Blue Guardian's Real Total Cost includes activation fees and safety buffer requirements, giving Blue Guardian a Fairness Score of 1798 pts compared to The5ers's 1746 pts.
Blue Guardian enforces a 100% Static Max Drawdown on 2-Step Standard (8%), 2-Step Pro (10%), 1-Step (6%), and 3-Step (8%); 6% Trailing Drawdown locking at Starting Balance on Instant Funding. Balance/Equity Daily Drawdown (3%–5%). calculation, while The5ers uses a 100% Static Max Drawdown based on initial starting balance (never trails upward). Balance-based daily pause (3% to 5%) depending on program. model. For Forex traders, drawdown calculation is the critical risk factor: trailing drawdowns update as peak equity rises, whereas End-of-Day (EOD) or static drawdowns only calculate from closed session balances. LogToLast's Post-Trade Drawdown Engine recalculates your locked equity buffer after every closed fill, while the mechanical Playbook Active Enforcer blocks webhooks or closes positions if daily loss limits are breached.
Blue Guardian supports MT5, cTrader, DXtrade, TradeLocker, whereas The5ers supports MT5, cTrader, TradingView. LogToLast supports automated trade syncing and ~15–35ms TradingView webhook routing for both ecosystems via Tradovate and MT5.
Blue Guardian offers a 85% profit split with payouts processed Every 7 Days (Instant Funding & Instant Starter $5K) / Bi-Weekly 14 Days (1-Step, 2-Step & 3-Step) — Backed by 100% Payout Speed Guarantee via RiseWorks & Crypto (minimum withdrawal: $100), while The5ers provides a 80% split with payouts processed Bi-weekly on-demand payouts processed in 24–48 hours via Rise Pay, Bank Wire, Crypto (USDT), Card & HUB Credits (minimum withdrawal: $150). Traders should also note consistency rules: Blue Guardian enforces 0% consistency during 1-Step, 2-Step, and 3-Step evaluations (5 min days of >=0.5% profit). 20% Consistency Rule across ALL Funded and Instant accounts (best day <= 20% of total profit)., compared to The5ers's 3 Profitable Days (>=0.5% profit) required on High Stakes; zero consistency rules on Bootcamp, Hyper Growth, and Summer Plan..
Blue Guardian's copy trading policy is: 'Permitted across personal accounts owned and operated by the same trader up to $400,000 maximum allocation via MT5 Local Bridge. Prohibited on Instant Starter $5K accounts. Third-party signal copying and HFT/latency arbitrage are strictly banned.'. Meanwhile, The5ers's policy is: 'Personal copy trading permitted between High Stakes, Summer Plan, Pro Growth and Hyper Growth accounts up to $500,000 total capital allocation. Copying from personal external master account permitted. Copying between two Bootcamp accounts is strictly prohibited.'. Where permitted by firm rules and supported on MT5/Tradovate, LogToLast applies automated risk multipliers and compliance safeguards; note that LogToLast syncs only supported MT5/Tradovate firms (Blue Guardian: Sync Supported, The5ers: Sync Supported).
Coupon copied to clipboard!